
Pick a budget, not a plan.
An ICHRA lets you decide exactly what to contribute while each employee chooses their own individual health plan. Here's how it compares with a group plan, and how to tell which fits your business.
Why owners ask about ICHRAs
We hear the same three stories from Northern Colorado business owners.
A group plan never got off the ground
Too expensive, or you couldn't meet the carrier's participation rules. An ICHRA has no participation minimum.
You're tired of being the plan wizard
Two or three plan options still never make everyone happy. With an ICHRA, each employee picks their own.
Renewals keep outrunning the budget
Capping your contribution stops the bleeding, and you're still offering a real benefit.
How an ICHRA works
You fund it. Employees shop. Reimbursements come back tax-free.
You set an allowance
A fixed monthly amount for each class of employee, such as full-time or part-time, salaried or hourly.
Employees pick a plan
Any individual plan that fits them, on or off Connect for Health Colorado.
They're reimbursed tax-free
Employees show proof of coverage and premiums, and reimbursements come back tax-free.
Payroll keeps it clean
Reimbursements and any pre-tax premium deductions are set up right, so nothing lands on the wrong line of a W-2.
Curious what plans cost? See individual plan prices in Larimer County
Three paths, side by side
Owners who learn about ICHRAs often end up in a group plan or giving a raise. Any of the three can be the right call.
- You control the costThe carrier sets the renewal
- Employees choose their planFrom the options you pick
- Tax-free to employeesPre-tax through Section 125
- Light on adminEnrollment, renewals, participation rules
- Premium tax credits stay possibleOnly if the plan is unaffordable
- You control the costYou set the allowance
- Employees choose their planAny individual plan
- Tax-free to employeesReimbursements are tax-free
- Light on adminNotices, proof of coverage, reimbursements
- Premium tax credits stay possibleIf declined and unaffordable
- You control the costYou set the amount
- Employees choose their planAny plan, or none
- Tax-free to employeesTaxed like any wages
- Light on adminJust payroll
- Premium tax credits stay possibleBased on household income
The one test that shapes the allowance
Whether an ICHRA counts as "affordable" for an employee decides whether they can still get a premium tax credit. Set the allowance with that in mind and you control your costs while getting the most value to your team.
- Allowances can differ by employee class; within a class, only by age and family size
- With 50 or more full-time (or equivalent) employees, an unaffordable offer can bring an employer penalty
- Under 50, there's no penalty, so you have more room to design
The employee uses the ICHRA. They can't also get a premium tax credit.
The employee picks one: take the ICHRA, or turn it down and claim a premium tax credit if they qualify. Never both.
Which path fits you? A 1-minute check
Four questions. No email required.
Do you offer a group health plan today?
ICHRA questions
Want the deep dive? Grove's ICHRA and QSEHRA guide covers the details.
Insurance is offered through Grove Benefit Advisors LLC, a licensed Colorado insurance agency (Colorado agency license 958957). Unify Payroll does not sell insurance. General information, not tax or legal advice.
Get real numbers for your team
Book a short call and we'll compare an ICHRA, a group plan, and a raise using your team's actual mix. Or send a question first.